Fitch Ratings has affirmed New Development Bank (NDB)'s Long-Term Issuer Default Rating (IDR) at 'AA+' with a Stable Outlook. Fitch has also affirmed NDB's Short-Term IDR at 'F1+'.
KEY RATING DRIVERS
NDB's 'AA+' rating continues to be driven by its existing and expected intrinsic features, based on Fitch's long-term projections. Given the relatively early years of development at NDB, Fitch bases its projections on an eight-year forecast period (2020-2027). The bank's intrinsic rating is underpinned by its solvency assessment of 'aa', which is the lower of its solvency and liquidity assessments. The bank's liquidity is assessed at 'aaa'. In Fitch's view, NDB operates in a 'medium-risk' business environment, which translates into a positive adjustment of one notch above its solvency assessment, resulting in an overall intrinsic rating of 'aa+'.
Fitch continues to consider NDB's capitalisation as 'excellent'. NDB was endowed with subscribed paid-in capital of USD10 billion, of which almost 70% had been received from the bank's five member states (MS) at end-March 2020. The 'excellent' assessment is principally driven by Fitch's expectation that both the equity-to-assets ratio and Fitch's risk-weighted capitalisation (FRA) ratio will remain above the respective 'excellent' thresholds of 25% and 35%. Fitch expects the equity-to-assets ratio to be just above 25% in 2027 and the FRA ratio to be around 45%.
In terms of profitability, whilst Fitch has slightly revised down its forecasts of NDB's internal capital generation (ICG) to average around 2.0% per year between 2020 and 2027 (previously 2.5%), this healthy ICG is in line with our expectations that NDB will continue to benefit from relatively high net interest margins on its non-sovereign operations (expected to account for about 25% of total loans) and will remain a lean and streamlined organisation, despite the expected move to significantly larger new headquarters.
Unlike some other multilateral development banks, NDB has not announced a formal COVID-19 response package. However, it has and will continue to support its members in dealing with crisis-related assistance, including health and social safety expenditure, as well as supporting MS' economic recovery. Fitch expects the bank's COVID-19 response to total around USD10 billion over the next two years.
To date, USD1 billion Emergency Assistance Program loans to China (19 March 2020), India (30 April 2020), Brazil (21 July 2020) and South Africa (19 June 2020) have been approved. The bank's response has led to a sharper-than-expected acceleration in the growth of the loan book in the short term (far greater than our expectation last year) but over the medium to long term we do not expect there to be an increase in the projected stock of loans by 2027.
Our assessment of NDB's risk profile is unchanged at 'low', which balances the bank's 'low' credit risk profile, its 'strong' risk management policies as well as its 'high-risk' concentration metrics. Fitch understands that NDB will lend to sovereign and non-sovereign entities based within its five MS, which had an average rating of 'BBB-' at end-2019. While this is unchanged from last year, since the last review of NDB there have been a number of sovereign rating actions taken on NDB's five MS; South Africa (downgraded to BB/Negative), Russia (upgraded to 'BBB'/Stable), India ('BBB-'/Outlook revised to Negative) and Brazil ('BB-'/Outlook revised to Negative). Fitch forecasts a one-notch lowering of the bank's average rating of loans by 2027 to 'BB+'.
In Fitch's view, the bank will benefit from 'strong' preferred creditor status (PCS), mainly reflecting repayment priority from its sovereign borrowers, which we expect to account for around 75% of total exposures by end-2027. After adjusting for NDB's 'strong' level of PCS (providing a two-notch uplift), this translates into a projected average rating of loans of 'BBB' for NDB, a high level relative to the universe of Fitch-rated supranationals.
In addition, we expect NDB's asset quality to remain relatively strong, with its NPL ratio expected to remain 'low' (around 2%), with impairments most-likely to materialise from non-sovereign borrowers. As of end-March 2020, all of NDB's outstanding loans were classified as 'stage 1' under the IFRS 9 accounting standard, reflecting that all were performing and that there had been no material weakening in the credit quality of these borrowers since initial recognition on the bank's books.
The relatively limited number of countries NDB expects to be operating in results in a 'high' level of concentration risk, which continues to be the bank's main rating weakness. Fitch understands that NDB continues to explore engaging in an Exposure Exchange Agreement (EEA), which consists of swapping some of its large credit exposures to sovereign borrowers with exposures held by other institutions, in order to improve its concentration metrics. While we expect NDB's potential participation in an EEA to improve its concentration risk by FYE 2027, we continue to expect the share of NDB's top-five borrowers relative to its total banking exposures to exceed 60% by 2027. Fitch does not currently incorporate in its projections potential opening of the bank's membership to new countries. If this were to happen it could increase diversification in the loan book and improve our assessment of the bank's concentration risk.
Fitch assesses NDB's risk management policies as 'strong', mainly reflecting the bank's self-imposed rules, primarily on capitalisation and liquidity metrics. Most of NDB's policies are prudent and in line with 'AAA' rated peers, including the bank's minimum equity/assets prudential threshold of 25%, adherence to which is instrumental in the maintenance of the bank's current solvency assessment. The rules on concentration limit any country exposure (sovereign plus non-sovereign) to the lower of 20% of subscribed capital or 30% of total approved loans. However, this policy will only come into force from 2021 and the loan book is currently skewed towards China and India.
The bank's policy of assessing sovereign credit risk by taking the highest sovereign rating for its MS from each of the three credit rating agencies, rather than the lowest or an average, is less conservative than peers. Our assessment also factors in the very strong level of aggregate expertise and seniority of the bank's current management team.
NDB's business environment assessment remains unchanged at 'medium-risk', which translates into a one-notch uplift for the intrinsic rating. NDB's 'medium-risk' operating environment reflects the 'medium' credit quality and political risk in most countries of operations, which may well be tested if the bank's limited shareholder base experience a series of negative sovereign rating actions. The 'medium-risk' assessment also reflects the strong operational support we expect the bank will receive from its MS, with an already tangible example of this support being NDB's new headquarters currently being built in Shanghai, funded by the Chinese authorities.
Fitch Ratings